top of page

The Judgement of Paris: A Turning Point in California Wine

In the world of wine, there are moments that stand out as pivotal, altering the course of history and reshaping the industry's landscape. One such moment occurred in 1976, in a blind tasting event known as the Judgement of Paris. This landmark event, which pitted French wines against up-and-coming Californian wines, forever changed the perception and prestige of wines from the Golden State.


Before the Judgement of Paris, California was not widely regarded as a serious contender in the world of wine. French wines, particularly those from Bordeaux and Burgundy, were considered the epitome of quality and sophistication. California, while producing wine for centuries, was still seen as a relative newcomer, lacking the tradition and heritage of its European counterparts.

Judgement of Paris wine tasting 1976

However, all of this changed on May 24, 1976, when Steven Spurrier, a British wine merchant, organized a blind tasting in Paris. The blind tasting competition pitted California wines against French wines, which were long considered the epitome of excellence. Distinguished judges from the French wine community were assigned the responsibility of choosing the best wines from both France and California.


To the shock of many, including Spurrier himself, the California wines performed exceptionally well. In the white wine category, a 1973 Chardonnay from Chateau Montelena, crafted by winemaker Mike Grgich, beat out renowned French counterparts, securing the top spot. Similarly, in the red wine category, a 1973 Cabernet Sauvignon from Stag's Leap Wine Cellars, crafted by Warren Winiarski, triumphed over esteemed Bordeaux wines.


The outcome of the Judgement of Paris sent shockwaves through the wine world. It shattered the perception of California wines as mere imitators and demonstrated that they could stand shoulder to shoulder with the best that France had to offer. Overnight, California winemakers gained newfound respect and recognition on the global stage.


The Judgement of Paris had several profound effects on the California wine industry:


International Recognition: The victory in Paris catapulted California wines onto the world stage, garnering attention and respect from wine enthusiasts and critics worldwide. This newfound recognition opened up export markets and expanded the reach of California wineries beyond the borders of the United States.


Investment and Expansion: The success of the Judgement of Paris attracted investment into the California wine industry. Entrepreneurs and investors saw the potential for growth and profitability, leading to an influx of capital that fueled the expansion of vineyards and wineries across the state.


Quality Focus: The Judgement of Paris highlighted the potential for quality winemaking in California. Winemakers began to prioritize quality over quantity, adopting techniques from their European counterparts and experimenting with new grape varieties and terroirs. This focus on quality helped to elevate the overall standard of California wines.


Cultural Shift: The Judgement of Paris sparked a cultural shift in how California wines were perceived both domestically and internationally. Californian winemakers began to embrace their unique identity, celebrating the diversity of their terroirs and experimenting with innovative winemaking practices. Consumers, in turn, became more adventurous, seeking out new and exciting wines from California.


Rivalry and Innovation: The success of the Judgement of Paris ignited a friendly rivalry between California and France, spurring both regions to push the boundaries of winemaking. This spirit of competition fueled innovation and experimentation, leading to the development of new styles and techniques in both Old World and New World winemaking.


In hindsight, the Judgement of Paris was a watershed moment that forever changed the trajectory of the California wine industry. It shattered long-held perceptions, elevated the reputation of California wines, and set the stage for the state to become one of the world's premier wine-producing regions. More than just a tasting event, the Judgement of Paris was a testament to the power of passion, perseverance, and the pursuit of excellence in winemaking. An even more interesting was how this small event impacted the rest of the world. 

14 views0 comments


bottom of page